8/10
I was up until half five yesterday morning reading intensely to finish off this story. I didn’t write the review then as it would have been a tired, mumbled mess with little to no eloquence and it wouldn’t have included any cool sounding words. Let’s see how I get on now after a good nights sleep. Prior to reading this, I had completed Abercrombie’s Shattered Sea trilogy and enjoyed it a lot. Where that was classic story focused fantasy with twists aplenty, this is best described as a macabre, dark and twisted character study of morally questionable individuals. This narrative takes place in a world that seems to be brimming with a blood-splattered past, interesting races and a heightened amount of warmongering aggression between the countries and factions. There is a lot going on in Abercrombie’s world yet, it is a shame that the two versions of this book that I have didn’t include any cartographed maps. I did get a little confused trying to compose a mental map of the world and distinguish where the action was taking place.
The greatest accomplishment achieved by Abercrombie here is the characters he has created.
The four main individuals are:
Jezal: A vain, selfish nobleman and talented fencer.
Logan: An infamous warrior.
Glokta: A tortured and crippled torturer.
Bayaz: A mage whose motives are mystical.
I will not go into any real details about them, how they intertwine, their opinions shared in monologues regarding the others (if they meet that is) but it is a pleasure to read about these characters that are, on paper at least, completely unlikeable. There are times that these characters surprised me with their thoughts. Glokta’s internal opinions are darkly humorous yet tortuous when relating to his past, and the womaniser and dashing swordsman Jezal actually having some weird emotions for only one lady are two fine examples. The players’ interactions had a Tarantino-like quality.
This book was a slow burner for me. It has many great qualities but whilst reading I occasionally had an internal dilemma about whether I should put it down and pick up something with more action. Two or three amazing setpieces excluded (such as a fencing contest and Logan’s old gangs’ antics), it doesn’t really include many all-out adrenaline fueling segments. Towards the end, however; reading this was quite intense hence why I was up until stupid o’clock to finish the story. I reflect that this books main agenda was probably for the reader to get to know the characters because this is done extremely well. At the finale, the seams are brimming with reported conflicts and a bizarre proposed mission that the characters find out are their fates and destinies moving forward. To conclude, I have to admit that Before they are Hanged is set up phenomenally well and I am looking forward to shortly jump back into Abercrombie’s world.
Posted on: Fantasy Book Review
Seems like something is missing. Did you accidentally publish without the review?
LikeLike
No I didn’t. Cheers for pointing that out mate. I have no idea what has happened here…. Very bizarre.. Will re-post in the next minute or two.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Looking good now!
LikeLike
No idea why that happened mate 🙂 You read this one before?
LikeLiked by 1 person
I don’t read Abercrombie. He’s a bit too grim and morally ambiguous for me to enjoy.
LikeLike
You may like his Shattered Sea series. It isn’t really grim. More classic fantasy with cool characters, but not too deep and seems focused on presenting a kick-ass tale.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This sounds really good- I’m really hoping to read some of Abercrombie’s work at some point- I really like character based books from time to time so this sounds like a good place to start!
LikeLiked by 1 person
One of my all time favorite series , the last book in particular was the best every character driven fantasy book
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great review, I love Abercrombie’s work and The First Law trilogy is one of my all time favourites.😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was a bit upset with myself that I didn’t have more to say about it tbh. It is probably one of my shortest reviews. I am finishing an ARC I have and will hopefully start Before They Are Hanged later tonight 🙂 x
LikeLiked by 1 person
Staying up until Stupid o’Clock is a sure sign of an engaging read. Glad to hear you enjoyed it!
LikeLike
Hi there!
I have to admit, I acctually did put it down due to the lack of action. I started reading it after I finished the Shattered Sea series, knowing I couldn’t expect the same but still didn’t make it through the book. Perhaps I shall try again – your review might have done the trick. Also, I am interested in Before they are Hanged but I guess I should start at the beginning…
LikeLike
Yeah, 100% start at the beginning. There are a lot of great things about this series. If you get through it then let me know your views mate.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good summary and the book starts somewhat familiar but gradually subverts or twists every cliche in fantasy. Personally, I love how unsentimental the “romance” between Ardee and jezal turns out to be.
LikeLike